Talmud Class: Demoralized Israel - How Can We Help a Land we Love in a Troubled Time?
Summary: <p>When I was in Jerusalem last week sitting shiva for our father, after folks gave their condolences and shared their memories, they would ask me for my take on Israel. The conversation was sobering, making me feel naïve and disconnected from the real Israel that is.</p> <p>Me: In Greater Jewish Boston, we are so excited to be marking Israel at 75. A big contingent from our shul is going to celebrate Israel at 75! A big contingent from the whole Boston Jewish community is going to mark this joyful and incredible milestone! How are you thinking about Israel at 75?</p> <p>Comforters: One of two responses. The less common: “Not on our radar screen at all. We’ve given it no thought till you just mentioned it.” By far the more common: “I hope we get there. Not clear that we will make it to 75 as one country.”</p> <p>In the shiva house, I had the sinking feeling that there was not one death I was mourning, but two. Something has died in Israel beyond our father – a belief of Israelis in a bright future for Israel.</p> <p>Nothing makes that clearer than two titles of Danny Gordis. When he and his family made Aliyah in the 90s, during Oslo, his first book about Israel was called <em>If a Land Can Make You Cry.</em> The title evoked the pathos, the emotion, the ups and downs, the resilience, but the fundamental hopefulness of a nation whose national anthem is Hatikvah. That title seems long gone. The new title, from his piece this week: <em>Drowning in a Sea of Resentment and Hate,</em> <em>It’s Far from Clear that Israel Can Make it Back to Shore. </em><a href="https://danielgordis.substack.com/p/for-many-israelis-hatikvah-moments?utm_source=substack&utm_medium=email" rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank">This piece</a> details how numerous tribes within Israel—settlers, Haredis, Israeli Arabs, Palestinian Israelis, Ashkenazi, Mizrachi—feel betrayed (his word) by the state. One can sense this hate in the friction over dedicated <a href="https://danielgordis.substack.com/p/the-pilots-letter?utm_source=post-email-title&publication_id=296307&post_id=106774758&isFreemail=true&utm_medium=email" rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank">war hero pilots</a> who are protesting the erosion of Israeli democracy being called a “pathetic bunch of deserters” by the ruling coalition.</p> <p>What do we do about it?</p> <p>This week Thomas Friedman offered us another sobering <a href="https://files.constantcontact.com/d3875897501/0e7ee778-9aaf-47fa-a997-8dc2747592df.pdf?rdr=true" rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank">essay</a> with a sobering title: <em>“American Jews, You Have to Choose Sides on Israel.”</em> He quotes Rabbi Sharon Brous who speaks of rabbis giving Death by Israel sermons.</p> <p>Is he right? Is our response to this moment to see it as a political fork in the road, and we have to choose, and bear the consequences of our choice? Is there another way to frame and respond to this moment?</p> <p>How does <a href="https://www.templeemanuel.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/03/20230311-Talmud-class.pdf" rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank">our weekly Torah portion</a> (uncannily, it involves a civil war, a <em>milchemet achim,</em> in the wake of the sin of the golden calf) help us frame this sad and sober moment in the history of Israel? How can we help? Can we take a principled stand in favor of democracy and against Israel becoming an authoritarian regime without checks and balances without adding to the division of this moment?</p>
